IamRobin's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Thom.]

Dude did you and Ricky voice each other or have I forgotten what you sound like lol

ZachJaDa responds:

we voiced each other LMAO

[Wise Words]

Thank you, wise pikachu

[Captain Cookie]

A ZachJaDa animation on my birthday? How nice :)

ZachJaDa responds:

I made this 4 you, Birthday Boy.

[TED PARODY]

Hell yeah Ted rocks my g

That's my dood

That's MA BOOOOOOOOOOOIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

[Little Eyes]

For someone getting into animation, this is alright. I can definitely see you have potential and with time, you might be able to come back to this one day and feel inspired to re-animate it again, or perhaps even make something significantly better.

Sadly, having seen the previous description, I'm not sure you actually like the source the song is from. I see that you've updated it, and that's good, but combining that with your reply to the previous comment gives me the idea that you're bitter about whatever response you got. I'm gonna direct you to my interview with Andrew Allanson. Maybe it will help put things in perspective. https://iamrobin.newgrounds.com/news/post/1208635

I'd like to make clear my rating here is based purely on the art itself, not what you said in the original description. If that were taken into account, I would've scored even lower because to be blunt, what you wrote pissed me off. That's why I waited until I calmed down to leave this review.

Please remember the difference between cold, mean-spirited cynicism and constructive criticism in the future, or you won't get very far as an artist. I'm speaking from personal experience. I wish you the best of luck in the future with your art. If you want to contact me and talk privately, feel free to do so. I'm always down to speak to fellow artists, regardless of our differences.

Icy64 responds:

Hi there!, i actually do really like YIIK and i found its issues super relatable, i edited the description since it did seem like i was trying to be a dick and the only thing i dislike about the game is that the worst parts of the game could have been the best ( im not good at expressing this kinda stuff)

Im not really bitter about it but still a little bummed that it was a negative response, i mean i said that the game had great ideas but fucked them up, i couldnt have expected anything positive from that. Didnt mean to sound bitter in that other commet either. (Def gonna check out that interview, sounds interesting)

Really didnt mean to piss anyone off though, sure its not the nicest description but its honest, i chose to mention YIIK's flaws qs i found them extremely relatable as i feel like my creations have good ideas but fall on the execution like YIIK did, it was meant less as a criticism and more as a comparision.

Thanks for your feedback again i didnt mean to step on anyones toes

[Fiberglass Monkey]

16 years later, this still holds up.

[This is Friday Night Funkin']

Cock joke

[Friday Night Funkin PS1 Commerical]

Love this a lot.

[The Ultimate Showdown]

The song of a generation. Legendary.

[TANKMEN .5]

I have never seen Darkman.